Gin Fizz vs. Tom Collins

Unravelling the Distinctive delights of Two Classic Gin Cocktails

Gin lovers rejoice! In the world of cocktails, two classics stand out: the Gin Fizz and the Tom Collins. While both feature gin as the star ingredient, there are subtle differences that set them apart. Join us as we dive into the delightful details of these two refreshing drinks and uncover their distinctive attributes.

1. Ingredients

The foundation of any great cocktail lies in its ingredients. A Gin Fizz typically comprises gin, lemon juice, simple syrup, and soda water. On the other hand, a Tom Collins incorporates gin, lemon juice, simple syrup, and club soda. The main distinction lies in the choice between soda water and club soda, which affects the taste and effervescence of the drink. Both are carbonted water but there is a slight different in the composition. Soda water is tasteless while club soda has additional minerals such as sodium bicarbonate, potassium sulphate or sodium chloride. These minerals give club soda a slightly salty mineral like taste.

2. Preparation

When it comes to preparation, the Gin Fizz and Tom Collins share similarities but differ in technique. A Gin Fizz is traditionally made using the shake and strain method, where the ingredients are vigorously shaken with ice and strained into a glass. This provides the opportunity to add an egg white to create a silky foam. In contrast, a Tom Collins is built directly in the glass, starting with the gin, followed by lemon juice, simple syrup, and finally topped with club soda. The mixing method affects the texture and presentation of the cocktails.

3. Serving Style:

Another notable difference between the Gin Fizz and Tom Collins lies in their serving style. A Gin Fizz is typically served in a short glass, such as an Old Fashioned glass filled with or without ice. The cocktail’s frothy texture, resulting from the shaking process, is enhanced by adding egg white or ice to the glass, making it a visually appealing drink. On the other hand, a Tom Collins is served in a tall Collins glass, filled with ice and garnished with a lemon slice and cherry. The elongated glass showcases the cocktail’s effervescence and allows for a more refreshing sipping experience.

4. Flavor Profile

While both cocktails share a citrusy profile, they differ slightly in taste. The Gin Fizz, with its creamy texture and balanced sweetness, offers a smooth and refreshing experience. The lemon juice provides a tangy zing, while the soda water adds a light effervescence. In contrast, the Tom Collins leans towards a slightly drier and fizzier profile, thanks to the use of club soda. The lemon juice cuts through the gin’s botanical notes, creating a crisp and invigorating flavor.

5. Overall Sweetness

Both cocktails are made with gin, lemon juice, and soda water. However, a Gin Fizz typically includes less simple syrup to lemon juice, while a Tom Collins includes a larger amount of simple syrup relative to the lemon juice. This makes the Tom Collins slightly sweeter compared to the Gin Fizz. Overall, these two cocktails are similar in many ways, but the difference in sweetness and serving style sets them apart.


So, which cocktail should you choose: the Gin Fizz or the Tom Collins? The choice ultimately depends on personal preference, as both drinks offer a refreshing gin-based experience with their unique characteristics. Whether you prefer the creamy and frothy nature of a Gin Fizz or the drier and fizzier attributes of a Tom Collins, these classic cocktails are sure to elevate your gin-drinking adventures. So, gather your ingredients, shake or build, and savor the delights of these timeless libations!

Remember, experimentation is key in mixology, so don’t be afraid to add your own twist to these classic recipes using flavoured simple syrups. Cheers to enjoying the art of cocktail-making and discovering your favorite gin-based creation!

Home Bar Tips, Tricks and Sip Ideas: Sign Up!

Shopping Cart